Judge: DACA to Stay, Trump's Evidence to Repeal - "Erroneous"

Looking For A Positive In Immigration Reform

At the core of the plaintiffs' case, brought by 17 state attorneys general and immigrants impacted by the administration's rescinding of the Obama-era program, is that the decision to end DACA was arbitrary and therefore illegal.

In a tweet Tuesday, Trump asserts that Democrats and Republicans must act now to provide legal protections to young "Dreamer" immigrants in the USA illegally. But the judge said the reasoning behind its decision was flawed.

Tuesday's ruling, combined with a ruling from a California judge last month, means the program could end up going beyond the March 5 date. The federal court judge said the White House could potentially repeal DACA, but that the evidence it provided in the case was "legally inadequate" to prove the program's unconstitutionality.

Under Tuesday's ruling, the government must accept renewal applications only from people previously approved for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, not from people who were eligible but never applied. "The court concludes that defendants have not done so". Chuck Schumer of NY, expressed opposition to Trump's proposal.

Judge Garaufis said that was not a compelling argument, and said DACA is neither unconstitutional nor illegal. "We don't want them in and right now we're working on DACA, we're working on immigration bills and we're making them tough", Trump said. But on January 9, US District Judge William Alsup in San Francisco ordered the administration to partially revive the program and resume accepting renewal applications, finding that the challengers who sued over the rescission were likely to succeed in arguing that it was "arbitrary and capricious".

In a rare procedural move, the Justice Department appealed Alsup's decision directly to the Supreme Court. Garaufis made clear in his order that he wasn't requiring the administration to grant any applications, only to process them under the terms in place before the rescission was announced. Despite acknowledging the court's own sympathies towards those who were unable to apply for the program before then, "it can not say that plaintiffs have demonstrated either that these individuals would be irreparably harmed without injunctive relief or that the balance of equities favors these individuals to the same extent it favors existing DACA beneficiaries".

Justice Department spokesperson Devin O'Malley said in a statement that the department would continue to "vigorously" defend the administration's decision to end DACA.

CBP and ICE are two of the three primary federal immigration agencies, part of the sprawling Department of Homeland Security. "Promoting and enforcing the rule of law is vital to protecting a nation, its borders, and its citizens".

Related News:

  • Kerr hands coaching duties to Green, Iguodala as Warriors cruise past Suns

    Kerr hands coaching duties to Green, Iguodala as Warriors cruise past Suns

    Kerr said he told the players of his plan after the previous game and they ran the show for most of the day. The Suns will take on the Golden State Warriors tonight at Oracle Arena in Oakland. "It's their team.

    "Venom" unleashes its demons in teaser trailer

    Directed by Ruben Fleischer, Venom stars Tom Hardy , Michelle Williams , Riz Ahmed , Jenny Slate, Scott Haze and Woody Harrelson. In Sam Raimi's trilogy, the symbiote came from an unknown origin and found a new host with Peter Parker/Spider-Man.
    White House to Pull Nominee to Head Environment Council

    White House to Pull Nominee to Head Environment Council

    White on a party-line vote, but her nomination languished at the end of 2017. The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee approved Ms.
  • Killed, Dozens Injured in Hong Kong Bus Crash

    Killed, Dozens Injured in Hong Kong Bus Crash

    Most of the passengers were horse racing fans, as the bus was travelling on a special route for horse racing days. A press release from Hong Kong authorities today revealed that 18 perished at the scene of the accident.
    OH  police officers killed responding to 911 hang-up

    OH police officers killed responding to 911 hang-up

    The suspect, who has not been identified, was taken into custody and transported to OSU Wexner Medical. According to 10TV, one officer was killed on scene Saturday during a gunfire exchange with a suspect.
    Are There North Koreans at the Winter Olympics?

    Are There North Koreans at the Winter Olympics?

    After her elevation, the US Treasury Department had reportedly included her on the list of blacklisted officials of North Korea . After addressing the troops, Pence will fly to South Korea to attend Friday's opening ceremony of the Winter Olympics .
  • Fennville teen makes it to Space X launch

    Fennville teen makes it to Space X launch

    Several minutes after liftoff, they split off from the core and made their way back down to Cape Canaveral. In the meantime, SpaceX still has a full slate of Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy launches on tap in 2018.
    Paul Ryan Brags About Giving Public School Employee $1.50

    Paul Ryan Brags About Giving Public School Employee $1.50

    The tax bill cost almost $1.5 trillion dollars, while the teacher in question is only seeing $1.50 extra in her weekly paycheck. Ryan on Saturday posted a Tweet noting the secretary's increase and linking to the AP story.
  • Arsenal's woeful North London Derby

    Arsenal's woeful North London Derby

    But this morning, in this season's second North London Derby , Tottenham would do just enough to hold off Arsenal . Any hopes Wenger had of making the top four are fading fast with 11 games remaining.
    'A good young man' | Locust Grove police officer shot and killed identified

    'A good young man' | Locust Grove police officer shot and killed identified

    Price said Maddox had a young child, and his wife is pregnant and due to give birth to their second child "any day". I've never had any issues and I pray I don't have any, said Rodgers, who has lived there almost two years".
    Drilling Down Into NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA)

    Drilling Down Into NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA)

    Masimo Corporation, a medical technology company, develops, makes, and markets noninvasive monitoring technologies worldwide. Byron Michael sold $69,943 worth of stock. $186,130 worth of Masimo Corporation (NASDAQ:MASI) was sold by FITCH SANFORD.


Most liked

South Africa's Ramaphosa says working to resolve issue of Zuma's future
In the last several years, South Africa's political turmoil has also led to economic uncertainty. Zuma , whose presidency has been marked by numerous scandals, has stubbornly refused to budge.

Indian reporter working for leading media organisation arrested in Maldives
The detention came as the island nation continued with the Emergency which was declared by President Abdulla Yameen on Monday. However, the ministry stressed that it is not illegal for Israelis to visit the Indian Ocean island nation.

Millennium man Gerard makes history with Olympic first
Gerard's score of 87.16 is what won him the gold, and it came after a shaky run in the first heat with some sketchy landings. And it cemented itself on Sunday as he waited for four of the sport's most dominant riders to take their final runs.

U.S. drone strike kills top Taliban commander, three Haqqani terrorists in Waziristan
Even so, Pakistan Foreign Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif said the barrier should be finished by the end of 2019. When asked to comment on Trump's tweets, Asif reiterated that "both sides are trying to decrease the stress".

Dow Jones crashes near 600 points as global market unease persists
Many market watchers have been predicting a pullback, saying stock prices have become too expensive relative to company earnings. The Dow fell 1,032.89 points Thursday to 23,860.46, which is 10.4 percent below its record close of 26,616.71 set on January 26.

India defeat SA in 3rd ODI, here are records broken
South Africa will hope they can shift the momentum by winning the 4th ODI and change the tide of the tournament in their favour. The SA batting is now looking to De Villiers to salvage some reputation in the 4th ODI which he will be playing.

Guillem Balague offers hope to Liverpool in Isco pursuit
Some reports in Spain have claimed Isco wants to leave, but Zidane said: "What has been said is not true". It was planned to change him, and that's all ", he continued. "We must try and be more consistent".

Pelosi delivers the longest speech in the House's history to save DACA
White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said Pelosi "should not hold our military hostage over a separate issue". Senate leaders are working to finalize a two-year budget deal that would satisfy both Republicans and Democrats.

Pakistani community in UAE observes Kashmir solidarity day
Dukhtaran-e-Millat (DeM) in a statement said its activists raised flags and banners and marched at several places on Monday. The CM assured the Kashmiri people that the people of Pakistan will never abandon their unflinching support for them.

Six Nations 2018: Ben Youngs breaks silence after harrowing knee injury
A lot of people may get to this age and try to hang on, but I'm not interested in that. It's always good to know what he wants from you.

'Westworld' Season Two: Premiere Date Revealed & Trailer Aired In Super Bowl Ad
For the United Kingdom , as with most big HBO shows, that means it airs on Sky Atlantic, and season 2 will be no exception. In the preview, a calm, serene scene is presented, promising "a attractive world" as horses run through the countryside.

Premier League team of the weekend includes Mkhitaryan, Sanchez and Salah

No Mahrez again as Leicester held by Swansea in EPL
According to BBC Sport , Man City thought Leicester wanted £95 million plus Patrick Roberts in exchange for Mahrez. City were believed to be only willing to pay up to £65m.

LoC firing:Army officer among four martyred,three injured in Rajouri
Last week, the Pak army also targeted military and civilian facilities in almost a dozen areas of the Balakote sector. Several hundreds have abandoned their homes close to the border, leaving behind cattle and crops.

Jose Mourinho criticises 'quiet' Old Trafford atmosphere
It all started for United in as early as the 11th second when a well-worked move was converted into the net by Christian Eriksen. It was the first goal United had conceded in over 600 minutes of Premier League football.