Ex-CMs not entitled to residential accommodation from govt, says Supreme Court

Former CMs not entitled to government bungalows SC quashes rule made under Akhilesh Yadav govt

The law of govt bungalows was passed in August 2016, by the then CM Akhilesh Yadav.

All the former Chief Ministers of Uttar Pradesh will have to vacant their palatial government bungalows within two months as the Yogi Adityanath government has made a decision to issue notices to comply with the Supreme Court order quashing law passed by erstwhile Akhilesh Yadav government overruling earlier order of the apex court.

The bench said a chief minister, once he/she demits office, is at par with the citizen, though by virtue of the office held, he/she may be entitled to security and other protocol. The NGO argued that as per SC's ruling, allotment of government bungalows to former CMs was bad in law.

The court had earlier said that it had given an opportunity to the Centre and all states to express their views on the issue since its verdict might have an impact on any such rules framed by other states or the union government. The plea had challenged the decision of the government to allot official bungalows to Chief Ministers after their tenure in the office got over. The bench said the impugned legislation can very well be construed to be an attempt to overreach the judgment of this court.

"Section 4 (3) of the Uttar Pradesh Ministers (Salaries, Allowances and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1981 would have the effect of creating a separate class of citizens for conferment of benefits by way of distribution of public property on the basis of previous public office held by them".

The Supreme Court's verdict came on a petition filed by NGO Lok Prahari against laws enacted by the U.P. State Assembly which which allows former CMs and ministers official bungalows and staff at public expense.

It added, "We have extensively relied on the preamble of the Constitution which embodies the principle of equality and recognizes only a single class of citizens".

The Logical Indian wholeheartedly supports the apex court's judgement. The matter raises a substantial question of law: "Whether the equality clause contained in Article 14 of the Constitution of India enables public houses to be retained by persons even after they demit office?"

Related News:



Most liked

Suarez: LaLiga Star Will Be Welcomed At Barca
Bartomeu told radio station RAC1: "We are analysing the season and we will see what we will do with ins and outs". Barcelona have enjoyed a superb 2017-18 campaign, winning La Liga and the Copa del Rey.

USA man eats 30000th Big Mac
Guinness World Records has recognised Gorske for the most Big Macs consumed since 2016, when his tally was 28,788. After he was honoured, he did exactly what you'd expect - he bought another Big Mac to eat when he got home.

Death toll of Pakistan's coal mine collapses rises to 23
Rescue teams, including Personnel of Frontier Corps, Levies and Quick Response Force, were immediately called on the site. Two workers were rescued in an unconscious state, while bodies of two miners were recovered last night, an official said.

Fiala likely to play for Predators in Game 5 against Jets
Nashville opened the scoring with 2:40 left in the first when Hartman scored his second of the playoffs off a scramble in front. Flying somewhat under the radar is that the series also features two of the three goaltenders nominated for the Vezina Trophy .

Ferguson recovering in hospital following brain surgery
Midfielder Michael Carrick said he was "absolutely devastated", adding, "All my thoughts and prayers are with him and his family". The Scot won a staggering 49 trophies in management, including 13 Premier League titles and two Champions Leagues.

Bay Area Free Comic Book Day 2018 Guide
Preston is once again gearing up for the biggest day in the calendar year for comic book fans worldwide. In order to answer that question though, you'll need to know where your local comic book store is.

Neymar return to Paris boosts 2018 FIFA World Cup hopes
I'm happy here, but the club needs to bring in players and, for that, they have to sell other players. "Honestly, I am under contract until 2020 and I am 31".

Former VW CEO Martin Winterkorn indicted in MI
The 70-year-old resigned soon after the scandal over polluting vehicles in the United States became public in September 2015. Winterkorn faces four counts, including conspiracy to defraud the United States and wire fraud.

Bill Cosby's wife slams prosecutor for husband's guilty verdict
Camille Cosby has been his rock for over five decades, but it remains to be seen how she will respond when he begins serving time. A Facebook post by an angry Camille Cosby says Bill Cosby conviction is the result of 'exploitive and corrupt people'.

United States dollar climbs on positive inflation data
Consumer prices stayed flat in the month of March itself, while consumer prices minus volatile food and energy rose 0.2 percent. The government reported last Friday that wages and salaries recorded their biggest increase in 11 years in the first quarter.

Comey questions Trump's credibility and House Republican report
"I was concerned about his commitment to truth telling, based on some things I'd see during the campaign" Comey explained. Comey and Lynch should be brought before Congress and put under oath to "resolve this conflict", Graham said.

Trump to meet crew of deadly Southwest Airlines flight
"The actions of the crew and passengers of Southwest Flight 1380 show the great character of our nation", Trump said at his desk. Shultz was one of the first female fighter pilot in Navy history and has also said flying is her way of witnessing God firsthand.

Suspected 'Golden State Killer' Joseph James DeAngelo appears in court
Holes, a cold case expert and retired Contra Costa County District Attorney inspector, said GEDMatch was his team's biggest tool. Major commercial DNA companies say they do not give law enforcement access their genetic data without a court order.

Avengers wonder why 'Ant-Man and the Wasp' weren't in 'Infinity War'
However, the first teaser trailer for Ant-Man and the Wasp revealed that he won't be able to stay out of trouble for long. ANT-MAN AND THE WASP is released in cinemas on 5 July 2018 in Australia, and on 6 July 2018 in the USA , from Disney.

John Legend brings the 'Arthur' meme to life in Google Duo Ad
West later shared footage of Legend playing the instrumental intro to his 2004 hit "Ordinary People " on a piano. Kanye West says he and John Legend have "agreed to disagree" about Donald Trump .