Roberts Joins Liberals To Block Louisiana Abortion Law

Supreme Court justices watch President Donald Trump's second State of the Union address. Brett Kavanaugh far right is newes

Although the Court now has a majority of five conservative Justices, one of them, Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr., voted with the Court's four more liberal Justices to put the law on hold temporarily.

The justices said by a 5-4 vote late Thursday that they will not allow Louisiana to put into effect a law that requires abortion providers to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals.

Thursday's action again demonstrates Roberts' role as the key vote on abortion in the Supreme Court, said CNN analyst and University of Texas law professor Steve Vladeck.

In his dissent, Kavanaugh said there was a dispute about whether the physicians in the Louisiana case could obtain admitting privileges, and that a 45-day grace period would have provided time to settle that question.

The Supreme Court is now likely to take up the clinic's appeal of a lower court ruling allowing the law, with a decision on the merits possible in 2020, just months before the US presidential election.

An abortion business, Hope Medical Group, had gone to court to challenge the law's requirement that abortionists have "admitting privileges" at a hospital within 30 miles of their abortion business.

Beyond the Louisiana law - which resembles a Texas law struck down by the Supreme Court in 2016 - many other anti-abortion measures are being litigated in the courts or being considered in this year's legislative sessions.

Ed Whelan, president of the Ethics and Public Policy Center and a contributor to National Review, said in a February 8 post he does not think Roberts' vote for the stay "signals anything about how he will rule on the merits of the case". He is, by most measures, a very conservative justice, but he seems determined to keep the court from moving too far right too fast and being perceived as just another forum for partisan politics in Washington.

The court will decide soon whether to hear Indiana's bid to revive a state ban on abortions performed due to the sex or race of the fetus or evidence of disability.

Justices often feel bound by a prior decision of the court, even one they disagree with, at least until the court formally takes on a case to consider overruling the earlier decision.

Justice Anthony Kennedy had cast the deciding vote to block the Texas access law, but was replaced by Kavanaugh a year ago.

Has Roberts "committed himself to reaffirming Whole Woman's Health or any of the court's other abortion decisions?"

Kennedy backed abortion rights in two key cases.

That's because as it stands now, state laws are not allowed to place an "undue burden" on a woman's right to choose, putting so many obstacles in her path that it becomes hard or impossible for her to exercise her rights. He wrote that the Court needs more facts about the impact of the Louisiana law before putting enforcement on hold.

States on the other side of the divide are fighting back to preserve access to reproductive health care.

If "one or two of the three clinics would not be able to continue providing abortions ... then even the state acknowledges that the new law might be deemed to impose an undue burden for purposes of Whole Woman's Health", Kavanaugh wrote. He said those doctors would need to make a "good faith effort" to demonstrate that the law hinders abortion access. If they're going to eventually uphold the Louisiana law anyway, it's much better not to be so obvious that they're just out to destroy abortion rights wherever they can.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote a dissent from granting the stay, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch.

It was signed into law in 2014, but a federal judge blocked it, later ruling the law unconstitutional.

And when they do uphold the Louisiana law after a full hearing, that's what Roberts will accomplish.

The Supreme Court is the final defense against unsafe and unconstitutional attacks on basic rights and freedoms that affect the most important parts of our lives. The court will likely hear a challenge in the fall, during its next term.

Related News:



Most liked

Warren kicks off 2020 campaign with big-name endorsement
Some Democrats encouraged Warren to challenge Hillary Clinton for the party's presidential nomination in 2016, but she demurred. In the announcement, she called President Trump "the latest - and most extreme - symptom of what's gone wrong in America".

LeBron James Says There's Nothing He's Chasing in the League
James coveted Ben Simmons and convinced Antetokounmpo to work out a deal for Russell Westbrook . LeBron James selected longtime rival Kevin Durant with the first pick in the All-Star draft.

Frank Robinson dead: Baseball's first black manager in MLB dead at 83
His 1961 Reds team lost the Series to the Yankees in five games while his 1969 Orioles lost that World Series to the Miracle Mets. He also became manager of the Cleveland Indians in 1975, becoming the first black manager in Major League Baseball history.

LEAKED: Trump's day is 60 percent unstructured
White House officials are expressing anger after an insider leaked months of President Donald Trump's private schedules. In January 2018 , a similar leak to the same publication introduced "executive time" to an incredulous world.

Ariana Grande not performing at The Grammys 2019
Variety reported yesterday that Grande has pulled out from both performing and attending the event this weekend, February 10. Ariana was all set to perform but then had a disagreement with the show's producers over which songs she would perform.

Kylie Jenner Shares Intimate Family Video To Celebrate 'Angel' Stormi's First Birthday
Cape Town - Kylie Jenner trolled herself, and the entire world, when she joked about a second baby announcement. Still, it seems like the couple is definitely thinking about growing their fam and we are here for it.

Maduro rejects ultimatum from European Union , urges Trump to stop intefering
Sanchez added he wanted to spearhead a plan of humanitarian aid for Venezuela in the European Union and United Nations. On Monday, Maduro said he had written to Pope Francis, urging him to play a mediating role.

Sheriff: MMA fighter facing 'pending murder charges' escapes
Marks has three pending murder charges against him, authorities said, adding that he is considered to be "extremely unsafe ". The Montgomery County ( Texas ) Sheriff's office did not reveal which three murder charges Marks is facing.

5 things we learned - Unai Emery got it wrong
However, Unai Emery insists they will not adopt the defensive style of Newcastle to defeat the Sky Blues. The Arsenal boss has options on the bench if needed, including Denis Suarez and Mesut Ozil .

Virginia Governor Ralph Northam apologies for ‘disgusting’ racist yearbook photos
Republican state Senator Bryce Reeves said in a statement that Northam should resign if the reports of the photos are accurate. That said, Holsworth said that Northam admitted that if he can not govern, he will have to revisit the issue.

Did a Russian Plane Take Off With Venezuela's Gold?
It comes on the heels of the Trump administration officially recognizing Guaidó as the official president of Venezuela. Guaido appeared at his building with his wife and daughter, saying , "They will not intimidate this family".

‘Fortnite’ finally supports Bluetooth controllers on iOS and Android
Losing traction on the battlefield can be a frustrating and debilitating move, especially if a Victory Royale is close at hand. If you happen to any of the three devices mentioned above then you are set to enjoy the 60 fps goodness on your device.

Mario Kart mobile game delayed until summer
Exactly a year ago , Nintendo announced that a Mario Kart game for iPhone and Android would be launched by the end of March 2019. Nintendo earlier had a target of 20 million Switches sold through during the financial year, this has now been lowered.

Huawei’s Meng appears in court as Canada mulls US extradition
Officials of the administration of President Donald Trump say the Huawei case and the trade negotiations are separate issues. Department of Justice on Monday laid out a 10-count indictment charging Huawei with theft of trade secrets from T-Mobile.

United States hands bank accounts to Venezuela's Guaido
Mnuchin said that Citgo would be able to continue to operate but won't be allowed to remit money to the Maduro regime. That all changed on Monday when the US Treasury department announced sanctions on PDVSA, the state oil monopoly.